In an age of unprecedented connectivity and information access, a darker force has emerged to challenge the very foundations of our democratic societies: disinformation. Disinformation, the deliberate creation and spread of false or misleading information, is not merely a harmless quirk of the digital age. It is a sophisticated and insidious weapon, deliberately designed to sow confusion, erode trust, manipulate public opinion, and ultimately undermine the pillars of democracy. Understanding its multifaceted nature is the first step toward building resilience and protecting our shared future.
Disinformation is not simply the accidental spread of inaccurate information (misinformation). It is a conscious and calculated act. It differs from simple mistakes or misunderstandings. It is a deliberate campaign of deception.
Here are some of its core characteristics:
1. Intentional Deception: The primary goal of disinformation is to deceive, not inform. It is designed to mislead and manipulate, often to achieve specific political, economic, or social objectives.
2. Strategic Manipulation: Disinformation is strategically designed to target specific audiences, exploit existing biases, and amplify existing divisions. It often relies on emotional manipulation rather than factual accuracy.
3. Rapid and Widespread Dissemination: Disinformation thrives on the speed and reach of digital platforms. It can spread virally across social media, reaching millions in a matter of hours, making it difficult to control or counter.
4. Use of Sophisticated Techniques: Disinformation campaigns employ a variety of sophisticated techniques, including fake news websites, deepfakes, bots, coordinated social media activity, and the use of algorithms to amplify misleading content.
5. Erosion of Trust: One of the primary goals of disinformation is to erode trust in legitimate institutions, including the media, government, and scientific bodies. This creates a climate of cynicism and uncertainty, making it easier to manipulate public opinion.
The corrosive effects of disinformation on democracy are far-reaching and devastating. Here’s how:
• Democracy relies on an informed citizenry capable of making rational choices based on accurate information. Disinformation floods the information ecosystem with falsehoods, making it difficult for people to discern fact from fiction.
• This directly impacts the ability of citizens to participate meaningfully in political discourse, and to make informed choices during elections.
• It results in polarization as people become entrenched in their own versions of "reality."
• Disinformation is often designed to exploit existing social divisions, inflaming tensions along lines of race, religion, politics, and social class.
• It creates echo chambers where people are only exposed to information that confirms their existing biases, making it increasingly difficult to engage in constructive dialogue across political divides.
• It promotes tribalism, eroding the sense of shared citizenship and common purpose that is essential for a functioning democracy.
• Disinformation targets democratic institutions, undermining public trust in the electoral process, the justice system, and other key pillars of democracy.
• It is often used to justify authoritarian actions and to attack the legitimacy of democratically elected governments.
• It creates a climate of instability that can be exploited by authoritarian actors, both domestically and internationally.
• Disinformation can be used to silence dissenting voices and suppress freedom of speech. It can create a hostile climate that discourages journalists, activists, and others from speaking out.
• This chilling effect undermines the marketplace of ideas, and weakens the ability of civil society to hold power accountable.
• Disinformation campaigns can be used to manipulate election outcomes. They may involve spreading false information about candidates, or creating a false narrative about voter fraud.
• This can lead to a loss of faith in the democratic process itself, encouraging voter apathy and instability.
• It opens the door for candidates to refuse election results, thus seriously damaging our democratic institutions.
• Disinformation deliberately targets the credibility of mainstream media. This can lead to a situation where people no longer know who or what to believe.
• This erosion of trust in media makes it harder for legitimate journalists to do their jobs, and creates an opening for unreliable sources of information to gain influence.
• Disinformation creates a fertile ground for the proliferation of conspiracy theories that undermine basic societal trust and create an alternate reality.
• Foreign actors and hostile regimes use disinformation to spread confusion and inflame existing tensions between nations.
Disinformation is a tool used by a variety of actors, with different motives and goals. Here are some key categories:
• Authoritarian governments use disinformation to suppress dissent, promote their own agendas, and weaken democratic adversaries.
• They invest heavily in state-sponsored propaganda outlets and online trolls to manipulate public opinion both domestically and abroad.
• They actively target democracies to sow division and instability, thus making them less powerful on the world stage.
• Extremist groups on both the left and right use disinformation to spread their ideologies, incite violence, and undermine democratic norms.
• They rely heavily on social media to amplify their messages and to recruit new members.
• Some individuals and companies use disinformation for financial gain, often by generating clickbait content or by selling fake products.
• These actors often take advantage of advertising networks to promote their disinformation and to generate financial gain from the exposure of their content.
• Some individuals intentionally spread disinformation for personal satisfaction, often in the form of online trolling or cyberbullying.
• They may be motivated by a desire to cause chaos and confusion or to inflict emotional damage.
Combating disinformation requires a comprehensive, multi-pronged approach:
• Educating the public about the nature of disinformation and how to identify it is crucial. This should be a core component of education at all levels.
• It involves teaching critical thinking skills and developing an awareness of the techniques used to spread disinformation.
• Supporting independent journalism, and its funding, is crucial for counteracting disinformation. A strong and free press is an essential check on power.
• Investing in investigative journalism and fact-checking organizations is vital to exposing falsehoods and promoting accountability.
• Social media platforms must be held accountable for the content they host and for the algorithms that amplify disinformation.
• This includes transparency about how their algorithms function, and the removal of known disinformation actors and sources.
• The promotion of better moderation practices.
• Open and transparent government practices make it harder for disinformation campaigns to take hold.
• This includes clear and accurate communication, and a willingness to engage with public concerns.
• Disinformation is a global problem that requires international cooperation.
• This includes sharing information, coordinating responses, and establishing international norms for online behavior.
• Empowering citizens to recognize, critically analyze, and resist disinformation is critical.
• Encouraging civic engagement and informed participation in public life.
Disinformation is a clear and present danger to democracy. It erodes trust, fuels division, and undermines the very foundations of our societies. Combating this threat requires a collective effort from governments, media organizations, tech companies, and all citizens. By promoting media literacy, supporting independent journalism, holding social media platforms accountable, and empowering individuals to think critically, we can build a more resilient and informed society, where truth prevails, and where democracy can thrive.
Bootleggers and Baptists
Candidate Accountability — A candidate's past is a window into their future.
Conspiracy theory
Deepfake — Misleading made-up photographs and videos: new threats for society and for democracy?
Disinformation and hate speech on social media
Fact-checking
Fake accounts on social networks
Foreign influence in local media landscape — Should foreign influence in local media be restricted?
Information Wars: How We Lost the Global Battle Against Disinformation — A book by Richard Stengel, Obama's Under Secretary of State.
Invisible Rulers: The People Who Turn Lies into Reality
Orwellian Doublespeak in today's political discourse
Propaganda
Springfield, Ohio, cat-eating hoax
The American Journalist Under Attack: Media, Trust, and Democracy
Truth and reality with Chinese characteristics — The building blocks of the propaganda system enabling CCP information campaigns.
DiR Renée DiResta
Tru Donald Trump — An existential threat to democracy
Erasing History: How Fascists rewrite the Past to Control the Future
Nineteen Eighty-Four
The Cult of Trump: A Leading Cult Expert Explains How the President Uses Mind Control
Ari Melber interviews Yuval Harari: Debunking Trump's lies
Fighting disinfo in MAGA era: Ari Melber talks facts & tech with Microsoft legend Steve Ballmer
Glenn Kirschner on Trump's legal issues for Haitian immigrant hoax
Integrity Institute
Disinformation is false information deliberately spread to deceive people. Disinformation is an orchestrated adversarial activity in which actors employ strategic deceptions and media manipulation tactics to advance political, military, or commercial goals.
Post-truth politics refer to a recent historical period where political culture is marked by public anxiety about what claims can be publicly accepted facts. It suggests that the public (not scientific or philosophical) distinction between truth and falsity—as well as honesty and lying—have become a focal concern of public life, and are viewed by popular commentators and academic researchers alike as having a consequential role in how politics operates in the early 21st century. It is regarded as especially being influenced by the arrival of new communication and media technologies.